Impact Evaulation

A guide for commissioners and managers


Thursday, January 1, 2015

Everyone in international development is familiar with the pressure to demonstrate their results, and to do so with “rigorous evidence”. Impact evaluations are a central part of that process.

Too often, a hierarchy of methods has been suggested, with randomised contolled trials (RCTs) placed at the top as the gold standard. Academic discussions have long moved beyond the notion of a hierarchy and promoted the importance of choosing methods that are appropriate to the type of intervention that is being evaluated and the questions being asked: Did the intervention work? To what extent did it work? Why and how did it work or not work?

But to date, knowledge of these diverse methods has been largely limited to experts and academics. To correct this, Bond, with support from DFID, Comic Relief and the Big Lottery Fund, commissioned Professor Elliot Stern to write Impact Evaluation: A Guide for Commissioners and Managers, which was launched this week.

The guide aims to empower commissioners of evaluations to make more informed choices about appropriate evaluation methods. Using the notion of a “design triangle”, it explains different, rigorous ways of showing the contribution of interventions to results, and how these can be considered along with different programme attributes and evaluation questions to choose which method is right for you.

Bond will be working on a practical tool for choosing evaluation methods to accompany this paper over the coming months. This will also complement Bond’s Evidence Principles and checklist, which can be used to assess the quality of evaluations, whichever methods are used.

Resource type: PDF

Related Resources

A child learning in Sudan
This learning paper provides a summary on why organisations need to collect disability data, what tools are available and practical ways in which these can be used.
3 December 2019
Man examines desert land for farming
Recommendations for future resilience programming.
2 July 2019
Syrian Children in Refugee camp
The most widely known and internationally recognized tool in the field of humanitarian standards. The latest edition reflects new evidence and evolving practice in the humanitarian sector
7 June 2019